Sisyphus Shrugged: "Joe Klein and his discontents"

Shocked, shocked!
Thanks to Sisyphus Shrugged for this great crosspost!
. . . and the Claude Rains Memorial Gambling Awareness Award goes to...
 Joe Klein, who is outraged to discover that Our Fearless Leader is not behaving rationally
The first three months of the new Democratic Congress have been neither terrible nor transcendent. A Pew poll had it about right: a substantial majority of the public remains happy the Democrats won in 2006, but neither Nancy Pelosi nor Harry Reid has dominated the public consciousness as Newt Gingrich did when the Republicans came to power in 1995. There is a reason for that. A much bigger story is unfolding: the epic collapse of the Bush Administration.
The three big Bush stories of 2007--the decision to "surge" in Iraq, the scandalous treatment of wounded veterans at the Walter Reed Army Medical Center and the firing of eight U.S. Attorneys for tawdry political reasons--precisely illuminate the three qualities that make this Administration one of the worst in American history: arrogance (the surge), incompetence (Walter Reed) and cynicism (the U.S. Attorneys).
Iraq comes first, as always. From the start, it has been obvious that personal motives have skewed the President's judgment about the war. Saddam tried to kill his dad; his dad didn't try hard enough to kill Saddam. There was payback to be had. But never was Bush's adolescent petulance more obvious than in his decision to ignore the Baker-Hamilton report and move in the exact opposite direction: adding troops and employing counterinsurgency tactics inappropriate to the situation on the ground. "There was no way he was going to accept [its findings] once the press began to portray the report as Daddy's friends coming to the rescue," a member of the Baker-Hamilton commission told me. As with Bush's invasion of Iraq, the decision to surge was made unilaterally, without adequate respect for history or military doctrine. Iraq was invaded with insufficient troops and planning; the surge was attempted with too few troops (especially non-Kurdish, Arabic-speaking Iraqis), a purposely misleading time line ("progress" by September) and, most important, the absence of a reliable Iraqi government.
General David Petraeus has repeatedly said, "A military solution to Iraq is not possible." Translation: This thing fails unless there is a political deal among the Shi'ites, Sunnis and Kurds. There is no such deal on the horizon, largely because of the President's aversion to talking to people he doesn't like. And while some Baghdad neighborhoods may be more peaceful--temporarily--as a result of the increased U.S. military presence, the story two years from now is likely to resemble the recent headlines from Tall 'Afar: dueling Sunni and Shi'ite massacres have destroyed order in a city famously pacified by counterinsurgency tactics in 2005. In the interest of balance, I should allow Joe Klein to respond here
The latest to make a fool of himself is Paul Krugman of the New York Times, who argues that those who favor the increase in troops are either cynical or delusional. Mostly the latter. Delusional neocons like Bill Kristol and Fred Kagan, to be precise. But what about retired General Jack Keane--whom Krugman doesn't mention--and the significant number of military intellectuals who have favored a labor-intensive counterinsurgency strategy in Baghdad for the past three years? They are serious people. They may be wrong about Iraq now, reflexively trying to complete a mission that has been lost, but they are not delusional. The counterinsurgency doctrine they published in 2006 is exactly what the U.S. military should be doing in places like Afghanistan. And they, not Kagan and Kristol, are the motivating force behind Bush's new policy. Mr. Klein goes on
On April 3, the President again accused Democrats of being "more interested in fighting political battles in Washington than providing our troops what they need." Such demagoguery is particularly outrageous given the Administration's inability to provide our troops "what they need" at the nation's premier hospital for veterans. The mold and decrepitude at Walter Reed are likely to be only the beginning of the tragedy, the latest example of incompetence in this Administration. "This is yet another aspect of war planning that wasn't done properly," says Paul Rieckhoff of Iraq and Afghanistan Veterans of America. "The entire VA hospital system is unprepared for the casualties of Iraq, especially the psychiatric casualties. A lot of vets are saying, 'This is our Katrina moment.' And they're right: this Administration governs badly because it doesn't care very much about governing." I believe Mr. Klein has an answer for that
And then there is the pessimism problem. Populists of both strains tend to believe that the system is rigged by dark and powerful forces that prevent the little guy from getting ahead, which means they tend to be angry. They also tend to be dividers rather than uniters. Even the nice-guy populism attempted by former Senator John Edwards in the last presidential campaign had a divisive edge. His theme was "two Americas." Pessimism, anger and unsubtle divisiveness tend to be total nonstarters in American politics. "Being optimistic is a patriotic value," says Diane Feldman. "If you are down on the United States, you are not patriotic." Most damningly, Mr. Klein shares this
Compared with Iraq and Walter Reed, the firing of the U.S. Attorneys is a relatively minor matter. It is true that U.S. Attorneys serve at the pleasure of the President, but they are political appointees of a special sort. They are partisans, obviously, but must appear to be above politics--not working to influence elections, for example--if public faith in the impartiality of the justice system is to be maintained. Once again Karl Rove's operation has corrupted a policy area--like national security--that should be off-limits to political operators.
When Bush came to office--installed by the Supreme Court after receiving fewer votes than Al Gore--I speculated that the new President would have to govern in a bipartisan manner to be successful. He chose the opposite path, and his hyper-partisanship has proved to be a travesty of governance and a comprehensive failure. I've tried to be respectful of the man and the office, but the three defining sins of the Bush Administration--arrogance, incompetence, cynicism--are congenital: they're part of his personality. They're not likely to change. And it is increasingly difficult to imagine yet another two years of slow bleed with a leader so clearly unfit to lead. Pwned. Mr. Klein knows better
Klein: I think that that's part of the answer, that certainly Bush and Cheney have run a big business oriented presidency, to their detriment. But also, you know, I spent time with George Bush when he was governor of Texas and he spent an awful lot of time talking about [and with poor people] and there were a lot of times that I saw him in 2000 him go into country-club Republican audiences and get tough questions about all these wetbacks and he would go right up into the face of those audiences, which was kind of like Newt Gingrich going into the face of the Evangelical Christians on Intelligent Design. I think that he truly believes that the people who are coming across the border, as I believe, are just coming over for the best of all possible reasons: to support their families, to work hard. [....]Every last motive that George W. Bush has isn't a malign one. You know, there are sometimes that the guy acts for what he considers to be the very best and the most moral of reasons. A lot of times I'll disagree with him, like going to war in Iraq, but, you know, I take him at face value in those things. I think, though, I should give the last word to Mr. Klein
And so the President finds himself in an exceedingly odd position for a post-Reagan Republican. He is acting like a Democrat, standing for abstract principles and high-minded long-term projects in the face of a public demanding easy answers and immediate results. His Middle East-democracy campaign is Wilsonian. Mr. Klein?
Bush's indifference to reality in Iraq is not an isolated case. It is the modus operandi of his Administration. Here, Mr. Klein earns his second icon.
Scamper, dear. Wouldn't want your tail to get wet.
- posted by Sisyphus ShruggedLabels: joe klein
Driftglass: "Jokeline - Proving Fake Journalism Has No Peer"
JokeLine continues to prove 
that when it comes godawful fake journalism he has no peer
Thanks to driftglass for this great joe klein takedown - THANKS DRIFTY!
(h/t to Atrios) As we all know, the Wingnut Waltz is a two-step: Step One is to simply declare that all liberals are hate-crazed, America-loathing traitors who sooner-or-later will have to be eliminated. This is their Final Solution to the Dirty Hippy problem, and on the Right there is now a virtual arms race to the bottom to see who can come the closest to calling for mass murder without actually saying it. Or, sometimes, just shouting it right out loud. Here, Jeffrey Feldman calls them by their True Name: The "Violent Right": In his newest book, The Enemy at Home, Republican ideologue Dinesh D'Souza calmly explains that liberals in America caused 9/11, whereupon he recommends that we do to liberals what we are doing to terrorists: fight a war against them. While he never comes right out and says that Americans should kill liberals, D'Souza's book shuttles his reader swiftly to that conclusion. By defining liberals as a "hidden" second front of terrorism, D'Souza's book invokes a very simple, widely held idea in America: that "War on Terror" means first and foremost, "kill terrorists." Thus, The Enemy at Home gives intellectual legitimacy to a widely accepted, rapidly growing Republican tendency to frame national security in terms of killing Democrats. The Right says these things, means them, are applauded for them, and then shrugs it off with a Tucker Carlson giggle as "just kidding" when caught and called on it. And let‚s be clear; the planning committee of the Hippycaust is a "Who's Who?" of Right Wing machers, who - no matter how rabidly insane their ravings - keep getting treated like serious people with serious opinions by the Main Stream Media. Keep getting invited back in front of the camera over and over and over and over again, regardless of how openly deranged they are. A rising tide of eliminationist-laced, rage-rhetoric from the Right shot through with the ideas that any compromise with the Left is Pure Evil (because the Left is Pure Evil), and that because this Force of Pure Evil that has worked since the dark days of FDR to destroy American, any means of annihilating them are ultimately justifiable. This has been going on now for decades, and the intentions and directions of the Violent Right are as clear as Mein Kampf. That‚s Step One. Step Two is equally simple. As long as the Radical Right is pounding away on the Left no-holds-barred and the Left continues to try to play nice and practice compromise (and be mocked and scorned for the effort) the MSM stays completely silent. They might occasionally crawl waaaay out on a limb and call Fred Phelps "controversial," but the rarified atmosphere of Telling The Fucking Truth is simply too much for them to stand for very long and they quickly scamper back into safety of the Land of the Cocktail Wienie and Nary a Discouraging Word. Only when the Radical Right is finally called out for their vile tactics and despicable ideology - in blunt, often-salty language - do the likes of JokeLine suddenly become intensely interested in breaking up the fight. Only when counterfire starts coming from the Left to finally challenge twenty years of saturation hatebombing from the Right do clowns like JokeLine decide to waddle their fat asses into the fray and wag a reproving finger - ...at the Evil Left. A left-wing extremist exhibits many, but not necessarily all, of the following attributes: --believes the United States is a fundamentally negative force in the world. --believes that American imperialism is the primary cause of Islamic radicalism. --believes that the decision to go to war in Iraq was not an individual case of monumental stupidity, but a consequence of America‚s fundamental imperialistic nature. --tends to blame America for the failures of others - i.e. the failure of our NATO allies to fulfill their responsibilities in Afghanistan. --doesn‚t believe that capitalism, carefully regulated and progressively taxed, is the best liberal idea in human history. --believes American society is fundamentally unfair (as opposed to having unfair aspects that need improvement). --believes that eternal problems like crime and poverty are the primarily the fault of society. --believes that America isn‚t really a democracy. He calls us fucking pottymouths too, which stung so deeply I had to put down my bong, leave my communist cell meeting just as we were dreaming up some outstanding new schemes to cause more abortions, help terrorists and further ruin America, go find a fat man with a monocle and a top hat carrying a bag of money marked with a Giant Dollar $ign and run him over with my Prius. Only then did I feel whole and smug and elite and Lefty again Go and read the whole thing if you want, but why is any serious news organization still paying this talentless, strawman-peddling, neocon to whore his delusions in print is beyond me. Well not entirely beyond me. I mean, JokeLine is basically writing for the 21st Century Archie Bunkers. Yahoos, hunkered down in their mental bungalows, living in terror of Those People. We‚re never quite sure who Those People are in specific detail (like names, locations, citations, etcetera) but like the survivors of a nuclear war, JokeLine's readers are holed-up in their psychic fallout shelters, listening to staticky radio transmissions from Bill O'Reilly and Rush Limbaugh warning them Not To Come Outside! That the blighted land is acrawl with Dirty Zombie Hippies who: A) Caused the nuclear war in the first place by being stupid, dope-smoking, bin Laden-appeasing peaceniks. B) Did not have the foresight to build and stock a spider-hole, because they, C) Didn‚t listen to JokeLine and the rest of the Wise Men, and, D) Will let the terrorists into your cellar fortress to rape your children and kill your dog if you so much as crack the door open to sniff the air outside. Of course there was no nuclear war and air is fine out here. The sun is shining. There are happy people walking around doing all kinds of normal things, but who are finally fed up with loud, ranting cranks locked in their basements taking potshots at them from the window because Rush or Sean or Ann told them the people out there were really all Dirty Zombie Elitist Hippies. And to sell his tripe to these rubes, JokeLine has to continue pretend to be objective. To continue to pretend to live in the mythical town of Centerville. And to live in Centerville, JokeLine and the rest of his ilk must continue to posit the boldfaced lie that the Left and the Right are equally and equipoisedly bad. That the 3% of crackpots and leftover communists on the Left are somehow equal to the armies of Coulters, Hannities, Dobsons, Falwells, O'Reillys, DeLays, Limbaughs, etc ad infinitum on the Right. That anger over the unconstrained spewings of powerful religious bigots on the Right in the name of their perversion of genuine Christianity is equal to being anti-religious. That anger over being called a traitor for 30 years by the Right while the media JokeLine shills for just sat back and let the bile roll over America unimpeded like Katrina consuming New Orleans is somehow inappropriate. That using the f-word is just as bad as lying us into a war and then f-ing it up beyond redemption. Which, in the end -- like JokeLine himself -- is just fucking ridiculous.
- posted by driftglassLabels: joe klein, wingnuttery
|