Taylor Marsh: "The New Sunni-Shiite Cold War"

He sure gets the scoops, doesn't he? hmmmm.
Thanks to TAYLOR MARSH for this insightful analysis of Hersh's newest article - THANK TAYLOR!
We can only hope it's a cold war. Seymour Hersh lays it out.
Think Iraq, only imagine the religious, tribal and sectarian carnage expanded throughout the Middle East. Got that picture? Welcome to Mr. Bush's long-term plan for the Middle East, pitting Sunnis and Shia in the hopes of allying the former with Israel to contain the latter.
Today on CNN, Seymour Hersh talked about Iran and his new piece just out on the realities we're currently facing. He talked about a plan wherein Mr. Bush will decide to strike Iran and get the job done in what is called a "24 hour package." The strike would be decided, launched and completed within 24 hours. They're cocked and loaded and ready to pull the trigger. Shhhh. Don't tell Congress. As Hersh also said, "I've been writing the same story for a year. ..." That's true, but this latest story from Hersh and The New Yorker has a whole different expanse and complexity to it.
After the revolution of 1979 brought a religious government to power, the United States broke with Iran and cultivated closer relations with the leaders of Sunni Arab states such as Jordan, Egypt, and Saudi Arabia. That calculation became more complex after the September 11th attacks, especially with regard to the Saudis. Al Qaeda is Sunni, and many of its operatives came from extremist religious circles inside Saudi Arabia. Before the invasion of Iraq, in 2003, Administration officials, influenced by neoconservative ideologues, assumed that a Shiite government there could provide a pro-American balance to Sunni extremists, since Iraq’s Shiite majority had been oppressed under Saddam Hussein. They ignored warnings from the intelligence community about the ties between Iraqi Shiite leaders and Iran, where some had lived in exile for years. Now, to the distress of the White House, Iran has forged a close relationship with the Shiite-dominated government of Prime Minister Nuri al-Maliki.
The new American policy, in its broad outlines, has been discussed publicly. In testimony before the Senate Foreign Relations Committee in January, Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice said that there is “a new strategic alignment in the Middle East,” separating “reformers” and “extremists”; she pointed to the Sunni states as centers of moderation, and said that Iran, Syria, and Hezbollah were “on the other side of that divide.” (Syria’s Sunni majority is dominated by the Alawi sect.) Iran and Syria, she said, “have made their choice and their choice is to destabilize.” The Redirection, by Seymour Hersh
Throughout his piece, which is a must read, Mr. Hersh neglects one important Iraqi actor, which Mash talked about yesterday: al-Hakim. Interesting that this central figure goes silent here. Hersh is no dummy so it's got to be by design rather than omission. I guess "stay tuned" is about all we can take from it for now.
Now, about our friends the Saudis. The key players behind the redirection are Vice-President Dick Cheney, the deputy national-security adviser Elliott Abrams, the departing Ambassador to Iraq (and nominee for United Nations Ambassador), Zalmay Khalilzad, and Prince Bandar bin Sultan, the Saudi national-security adviser. While Rice has been deeply involved in shaping the public policy, former and current officials said that the clandestine side has been guided by Cheney. (Cheney’s office and the White House declined to comment for this story; the Pentagon did not respond to specific queries but said, “The United States is not planning to go to war with Iran.”)
The policy shift has brought Saudi Arabia and Israel into a new strategic embrace, largely because both countries see Iran as an existential threat. They have been involved in direct talks, and the Saudis, who believe that greater stability in Israel and Palestine will give Iran less leverage in the region, have become more involved in Arab-Israeli negotiations.
The new strategy “is a major shift in American policy—it’s a sea change,” a U.S. government consultant with close ties to Israel said. The Sunni states “were petrified of a Shiite resurgence, and there was growing resentment with our gambling on the moderate Shiites in Iraq,” he said. “We cannot reverse the Shiite gain in Iraq, but we can contain it.”
(snip)
Martin Indyk, a senior State Department official in the Clinton Administration who also served as Ambassador to Israel, said that “the Middle East is heading into a serious Sunni-Shiite Cold War.” Indyk, who is the director of the Saban Center for Middle East Policy at the Brookings Institution, added that, in his opinion, it was not clear whether the White House was fully aware of the strategic implications of its new policy. “The White House is not just doubling the bet in Iraq,” he said. “It’s doubling the bet across the region. This could get very complicated. Everything is upside down.”
The issues swirling around Lebanon are what I've been hinting about recently, especially on radio, because there has been a "fitna" or civil war brewing since Olmert screwed up his over the top bombing of Lebanon, and did it so poorly that it not only emboldened Hezbollah, but left the entire region believing that Israel has a baffoon at the top. Olmert proved that not only was he incapable of understand military issues, but he didn't have the spine to back down once his blunder was exposed. This has left Lebanon vulnerable to all sorts of realities. More from Hersh:
In an interview in Beirut, a senior official in the Siniora government acknowledged that there were Sunni jihadists operating inside Lebanon. “We have a liberal attitude that allows Al Qaeda types to have a presence here,” he said. He related this to concerns that Iran or Syria might decide to turn Lebanon into a “theatre of conflict.”
(skip forward)
Nasrallah accused the Bush Administration of working with Israel to deliberately instigate fitna, an Arabic word that is used to mean “insurrection and fragmentation within Islam.” “In my opinion, there is a huge campaign through the media throughout the world to put each side up against the other,” he said. “I believe that all this is being run by American and Israeli intelligence.” (He did not provide any specific evidence for this.) He said that the U.S. war in Iraq had increased sectarian tensions, but argued that Hezbollah had tried to prevent them from spreading into Lebanon. (Sunni-Shiite confrontations increased, along with violence, in the weeks after we talked.)
Americans need to read up. This is getting very confusing for your average citizen, even for those who follow these things. The players are planning on the run to solidify turf, coupling with anything but the usual suspects, as they play with regional dynamite. It's one thing to want to move players around when enjoying a game of Risk, ala Dick Cheney. It's quite another to do it by throwing Israel and the Saudis together while Iraq is on boil.
So here is where we stand today. Iraq is in play, with the Saudis freaked out about ethnic cleansing and a Shia crescent, while the U.S. ratchets up tensions with Iran, who is linked in a swath of power from Iran to Lebanon, with Israel getting more nervous by the day and the Saudis offering up all the cash they've got to make certain that the Shia power is balanced with Sunni force, actually dipping their diplomatic toes into a relationship with Israel, all the while the United States agitates the situation, even though our influence in the region has plummeted, giving the Shia and the Iranians a leg up. Got that? ...and that's only the short version.
Now, getting out of Iraq won't begin to solve the challenges Mr. Bush and Dick Cheney have put into motion. The Sunni-Shiite cold war is on, but it's doubtful that any of these players will blink.
- posted by Taylor MarshLabels: Hersh, Iraq, Shia, sunni
Nikkos: "Why Sy Hersh is Wrong (just this once)"

Spot The Arab (by their style of doorway)
Thanks to NIKKOS who contributed this great piece on Sy Hersh - THANKS NIKKOS!
Hersh's latest piece in the New Yorker is as terrifying as usual. Among other things, it posits a shift (the "redirection" of the article's title) in the Bush administrations' strategy in the Middle East, specifically, an explicit decision to support Sunnis rather than Shia. If true, this would represent a stunning reversal in alliances, considering it was the virulently Sunni Al Qaeda that attacked the U.S. on 9/11 and that the U.S. is currently fighting a counter-insurgency war against Sunnis in support of the Shia Maliki government in Iraq. However, for anyone that's been watching the unfolding disaster which is the Bush administration, these sorts of vertigo-inducing paradoxes are par for the course.
As usual, it's hard to tell if these are acts of stupidity, strategy or desperation. The mind reels and grasps for a "logical" explanation, a narrative which can impose some semblance of order upon the chaos which Bush and his cronies seem to foment everywhere they traipse. And it is here where I think Hersh- or more accurately and fairly, his sources- get it wrong. They get it wrong because they seek to make to make sense out of what the Bush administration is doing, when there is, literally, no sense to be made of the situation. Or, to use a favorite phrase of the President, "in other words," what's going on here is not a rational re-alignment of alliances and interests in the pursuit of some rational goal- democracy, peace and stability in the Middle East, for instance. Rather, as has been amply documented, the Bush administration believes in "constructive chaos" in the Middle East; that is, the belief that, phoenix-like, a modern Middle East can emerge only from the flames of destruction. Therefore, conflict is to be embraced, not feared, for it is only through conflict that the Middle East can be reborn (though there may be some "pangs," as Condi pointed out).
When viewed in this context, then, Hersh's reporting makes more sense: it's not that we are switching sides; we're merely making sure both sides are properly armed and that as a whole, the region is left perpetually off-balance and unable to respond with any unity to the increasing hegemony of the United States. The increased tempo of this destabilization may in fact be part and parcel of an impending military strike against Iran- what better way to blunt a unified Middle Eastern response than to make sure the locals are busy fighting each other? Heck, it's just like in the good ol' days when we armed Saddam on the one hand and clandestinely armed the Iranians on the other. (Interestingly enough, Iran-Contra is back in the news, with reports that Negroponte stepped down from DNI in order to go to State precisely to avoid another Iran-Contra-like debacle which he saw brewing.)
So, yes, it IS a redirection- but not the kind Sy Hersh's sources envision.
- posted by NikkosLabels: Bush Iraq, Hersh, Negroponte, Shia, sunni
|